Lerman: ‘Jackson, Potter very different’

Posted on February 15, 2010 by Kyle King

This article was posted on Digital Spy today. Enjoy!

Percy Jackson And The Lightning Thief star Logan Lerman has spoken out about comparisons between his movie and the Harry Potter franchise.

The action fantasy revolves around a boy (Lerman) who discovers that he is half-human and half-god, and sets out on a quest with two friends to rescue his mother from the Underworld.

Speaking to BlackBook, he said: “I think a lot of people are saying that mainly because Chris Columbus’s name is attached to both films and we are selling it as, ‘From the director of Harry Potter‘.

“However, they’re different movies. Do we want it to be as successful and as loved [as] the Harry Potter films? Of course, but they’re pretty different stories.”

He added: “This movie is transferring Greek mythology into the modern day. It’s paralleling classic myths and introducing a new demi-god into the modern day world.”

Lerman, 18, previously said that his character had little in common with wizard Harry Potter “except that he’s an unlikely hero who’s been thrown into a huge situation”.

Article by Lara Martin

Source: Digital Spy

Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter: Round 3

Posted on February 10, 2010 by Kyle King

In the last post of this series we saw that Percy Jackson had the cooler weapon over Harry Potter. Today we will look at who has the better powers.

Magic and Powers

Percy Jackson has a fixed amount of powers that he can do. He can just be creative and explore his limits with water. Also water is the only thing that he can use his powers with and draw power from.

Harry Potter can learn how to do about anything other than trying to raise the dead. However the only fallback is that he needs to have a wand to channel his powers (it is possible to do magic without a wand but it is unfocused). A powerful wizard can do magic without speaking but most need to be able to speak to use magic.

Eragon Shadeslayer has powers that are based from the ancient language. His magical powers are limited to both his vocabulary in the ancient language and his strength. Magic consumes energy so that if you try to do something like lift a mountain it will consume your strength and kill you. This is my favorite magic because of the limitations on the magician.

If the three fought using only their magic and Percy was standing in water, especially ocean water I believe that it would be pretty much a tie between the three. Only creative magic would ultimately win.

Who do you think would win? Vote or leave a comment.

Is Percy Jackson’s mythology too close to Harry Potter’s magic? LA Times Article

Posted on January 30, 2010 by Kyle King

The Los Angeles Times had an article on November 18 about how close Harry Potter and Percy Jackson really are. Link to article. This article is very close to the Percy Jackson Movies series: Harry Potter vs Percy Jackson Fight Series. What do you think about the LA Times article? Leave your comments below.

Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter: Round 2

Posted on January 14, 2010 by Kyle King

In the first post of the series Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter we saw that Harry Potter would most likely beat Percy Jackson in a one-on-one physical fight between the two. Mostly owning to Percy downfall? Riptide, which cannot harm mortals.

However, that is not really what this series is about. This series will focus on the similarities and differences of the the two books into movies.

Today, who has the cooler weapon? A wand vs a sword.

The cooler weapon

Harry’s wand is a piece of holly with a feather of a phoenix (fawkes to be exact) created by Mr. Ollivander that channels Harry’s unfocused magic energy. But what of Riptide, Percy Jackson’s sword? Riptide has a mythological history…

Riptide was formerly owned and used by the demigod, Hercules. The sword originated as Zoë Nightshade’s hairclip, which she gave to Hercules to help him defeat the monster Ladon and is said to have the ocean as its source of power, which would explain why it works well for Percy. Riptide is made of celestial bronze which destroys monsters but cannot harm mortals. You can read more about Riptide here.

The two best features of riptide are its ability to always come back to the owner and secondly when sheathed it becomes a pen. Pretty useful to have a full sword in your pocket or for the geeks, in your pocket protector made of kevlar just in case you click it (movie edition of riptide)!

This one is an easy round to judge…the round goes to Percy Jackson and Riptide! Do you think that Percy should win? Leave your comments below.

Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter: Round 1

Posted on January 9, 2010 by Kyle King

Ever wonder what would happen if your favorite book characters had a one-on-one fight?

DING DING, Harry “The Chosen One” Potter VS Percy “Seaweed Brain” Jackson! First we are going to focus on combat weapons. Riptide vs Harry’s wand, yes I know that Harry ends up having the elder wand but that is later so we will look at book 1 vs book 1 (Sorcerer’s Stone vs Lightning Thief).

Strength of Weapon

A celestial bronze sword versus a wand made of holly? Not a chance, right? Celestial bronze cannot harm humans. Harry is a human…I guess…unless wizards are some other branch of the god family tree?

Percy can’t harm Harry with Riptide but Harry can hurt Percy except that Percy is trained at hand to hand combat as well and breaks that little holly wand in half with one good hit. It is possible to cast spells without using a wand, but for most wizards the results are unfocused. I guess if you put the two in a ring and told them to go at it they have a good 50-50 chance since Harry has good reflexes being a seeker and might be able to keep his wand unbroken. As long as he kept his distance and used range such as a bowman would. If he did this I think that Harry would would this match.

However, that is not all this is about. Harry versus Annabeth, Luke, Clarisse (daughter of Ares with electric spear) or most other Percy Jackson character…see ya later Potter! Percy versus Hermione Granger? Same result as Harry vs Percy.

Ultimately Riptide is much stronger than Harry’s wand but has no range.

This makes Harry Potter the winner of this round!

Percy Jackson Movies

Unofficial Percy Jackson Fansite

Category Archives: Harry Potter Fight Series