Your Heroes of Olympus Dreamcast: Piper McLean

Your Heroes of Olympus Dreamcast: Piper McLean

Each week, I’ll post a poll for each major character from Heroes of Olympus of which actor or actress you think would be best in the role. EgoTerreo chose most of the choices, but I added a few of my own or that I saw were popular online.

Last week we voted on Jason Grace and Alexander Ludwig won. We are moving on to the beauty queen, Piper McLean! I will profile each actress first and give some pros and cons of what I personally think. You can vote for your favorite at the bottom. In the comments, give me a reason why you chose the actress! You can also add to the poll your choice if its not one of the girls below.

Caitlin Stasey

Caitlin Stasey

Caitlin is 24 years old and a good age, if compared to Logan Lerman’s age. Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Caitlin has brown hair, brown eyes, and can always tan to look the part. She is Australian and may be able to do an American accent. Is is best known for starring in Neighbors, Tomorrow, When the War Began, All Cheerleaders Die, and I, Frankenstein.

Pros: I have seen her in I, Frankenstein and I can’t remember what accent she had, but I could easily see her as Piper.

Cons: None that I can think of…

Jessica Parker Kennedy

Jessica Parker Kennedy as Piper McLean

Jessica is 29 years old. Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Jessica has dark brown hair, brown eyes, and has tan skin. Is is best known for 50/50, In Time, Another Cinderella Story, and The Secret Circle.

Pros: She is beautiful and has a fun personality.

Cons: Her age, but Alexandra Daddario is a year younger than her, so it could work.

Kelsey Chow

Piper McLean Dreamcast Actress of Kelsey Chow

Kelsey is 22 years old, making him a great age for Piper. Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Kelsey is a perfect match with the brown hair and brown eyes. She was born to a Chinese Taiwanese father and a mother of English and Cherokee descent (Wiki). She is best known for The Amazing Spider-Man, Pair of Kings, Run, and Den Brother.

Pros: How perfect is she! She has Cherokee in her!!!

Cons: None.

Nina Dobrev

Piper McLean Dreamcast Actress of Nina Dobrev

Nina is 25 years old. Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Nina has brown hair, brown eyes, and is tan. She is best known for The Perks of Being a Wallflower (with Logan Lerman), Chloe, The Vampire Diaries, and Fugitive Pieces.

Pros: I have only seen her in one movie (The Roommate) and I can’t remember how she acts. Look wise, she appears to be great!

Cons: None.

Shelley Hennig

Piper McLean Dreamcast Actress of Shelley Hennig

Shelley is 27 years old. Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Shelley has brown hair, brown eyes, and can be tan. He is best known for The Secret Circle and Teen Wolf.

Pros: She looks right for Piper!

Cons: She is not the oldest in the list, but she looks to be the oldest. She may act longer than she looks, but I don’t think it makes her right for Piper’s age.

Victoria Justice

victoria justice

Victoria is 21, a great age for Piper! Piper is portrayed to be a very beautiful girl of Cherokee descent with dark tanned skin, chocolate brown hair, and eyes that change color like a kaleidoscope going from brown to blue to green according to The Wikia. Victoria has brown hair, brown eyes, and is tan. She is best known for Victorious, Zoey 101, Fun Size, and The First Time

Pros: When I posted my dreamcast for Heroes of Olympus several years ago, I had her as Piper and I still believe she would be great. However, that said, I think there are other great choices from the above list.

Cons: None.

Vote

Poll Closed.

Results
Caitlin Stasey: 20%
Jessica Parker Kennedy: 0%
Kelsey Chow: 51%
Nina Dobrev: 6%
Shelley Hennig: 6%
Victoria Justice: 17%

Idea Credit: EgoTerreo

 

Hey, I'm Rebecca! I'm a writer, an avid hiker, and rock climber. I love writing, from PJM posts to stories. Anything you want to know, just ask.

Share This Post

12 Comments

  1. Anna - June 4, 2017

    tbh i think that Kelsey Chow is the best because she’s a descendant of Cherokee and her eyes because brown is always the color that piper’s eyes always start out with & also she looks young enough

  2. Pamela - July 7, 2015

    I don’t think any of these would make a good Piper. But I do think that Barbara Palvin and Lucas Till would fit perfectly into these roles and they would make a perfect couple, as well. :)

  3. Christine Apa - December 29, 2014

    I WANT PIPER TO BE PLAYED BY VICTORIA!!

  4. kiapet - October 1, 2014

    I’m glad Kelsey won. The actress playing Piper should have actual native descent, not just look “tan”.

  5. EgoTerreo - August 7, 2014

    I voted for Kelsey. She’s just perfect for that role in my point of view.

  6. DJ - August 6, 2014

    I like Caitlin Stasey or Emma Roberts (brunette)

  7. Kieran - August 5, 2014

    Hmm… It was pretty close, but I voted!

  8. Gabby - August 5, 2014

    Caitlin is exactly how I pictured Piper to look like, but i chose Kelsey because i think she would be perfect. Nina is cool, i watch the vampire diaries, but she couldn’t do piper justice. Shelly is too intense, i watch teen wolf, to play piper. And Victoria is too upbeat to be piper.

  9. Rebecca King - August 5, 2014

    This was hard to make a choice with, but I voted!

Leave a Comment

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers:

%d bloggers like this: